Hoping to be the supreme gift giver this holiday season? Use these four simple steps to hone your skills and get off to the right start when creating the perfect holiday gift to celebrate your family and its unique history. Also, if you’re running out of time to make a gift this holiday season, here are some extra gift ideas that are guaranteed to excited family members and friends.
Dick Eastman posted an important story on his blog today. It concerns the destruction of records by the Clerk of Court for Franklin County, North Carolina. The records had been forgotten in the cellar over time, and covered a period from the 1840s through the 1860s. You can read more about what happened in a story by the Heritage Society of Franklin County.
This story is sad, but can be used as a cautionary tale. Records languish, forgotten in basements, attics, and storage areas in courthouses, city and town halls, and other government repositories. There are a number of reasons why this happens.
In most instances, it is not an intentional effort to hide records. The problem begins with a lack of proper storage space. Many government offices are small, out of date spaces. With all of the government cutbacks, there is often not enough money to pay for proper office supplies, let alone the furniture and space for the proper storage of records.
With the lack of space, government offices and agencies will find places to store older, little-used records. Often records are separated and placed in multiple locations. And these locations are not good for long-term storage, such as basements and attics.
Records languish and are forgotten because there is no need to access them on a regular basis. When government officers and employees are replaced, institutional memory goes with them. New employees may have no idea the records even exist, let alone where they are located.
When the records are found, there is a tendency to think that they are unnecessary, and to get rid of them. Unfortunately, a major issue is a lack of understanding of what records are important for genealogists and historians. Even archivists are not always aware of what “valuable” records are.
There are several things you can do to help save these records. The first thing to do is to educate the custodians of the records. The reason why so many of these problems happen is a lack of education. So teach them, for example, why dog registrations are valuable genealogical records (because they establish the presence of a person in a particular location at a particular time and place). Don’t try and do it alone, though.
As an individual, no matter how nice and friendly, it will be more difficult and challenging for you. Get your local historical and genealogical societies involved in the process. Work together to come up with a plan to educate government officials.
It is best to approach them in a friendly, non-threatening manner. Explain that other jurisdictions have had major problems, and you want to work with them to get their needs met before any issues arise in your area. And that is the key: approach them BEFORE a problem arises. Working with them this way is much easier than the adversarial positions that occur when trying to resolve issues in the heat of a controversial problem. Then you can make it a win-win scenario for everyone!
Few things are as frustrating to professional genealogists as people who claim to have traced their ancestry back to Adam and Eve. In fact, when someone comes up to me or writes to me explaining how fortunate they were to be able to do that, I immediately excuse myself. I try to do it without appearing rude, but anyone who believes that they can trace their ancestry that far back is not someone who is seriously interested in family history. They are interested in collecting names, and clearly do not care whether or not they are really related to them.
As a rule, most Americans whose ancestors immigrated here early in the development of the country might be able to trace their ancestors back to the seventeenth century. If you are lucky enough, you might be able to trace your ancestors back across the pond to Europe. Unfortunately, many disreputable people in the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries published a lot of undocumented information on European ancestry, much of which was completely made up out of whole cloth and has no basis in reality.
If you are fortunate, and can prove the genuine origins, you may be able to trace your ancestors into the sixteenth century. But for the vast majority of people, this is as far back as you can go. If you are lucky enough to have ancestors who were of the merchant class or higher, you might be able to identify additional relationships further back through probate and other records. But the church records that we depend on for much of the information did not exist earlier than this.
Although Cromwell ordered in 1538 that all baptisms, weddings, and burials were to be recorded, it is not until around 1558 that most records survive. Starting in 1597, a copy of the records was to be made and sent to the Bishop each year, greatly enhancing the number of records that survived.
In Catholic countries, the Council of Trent is the critical moment. The Council, which convened from 1545 to 1563, enacted the first law for recordkeeping in all Catholic parishes. Baptisms and marriages were recorded for almost all parishioners. Unfortunately, the book of the dead was not as meticulously kept in many areas, and there are many holes in the records.
Those who can prove their ancestry (and please not, I said “prove” not “find in some undocumented post”) back through the gentry to the royal families of Europe will be able to trace their ancestries further back. Yet even these start to have difficulties and problems when you start moving backwards through the Middle Ages (the 5th though the 15th centuries).
Anything prior to this time is pure supposition, with wide-ranging gaps. And leaps of six or seven hundred years are not exactly conducive to quality work. Stick to documentable facts and do your research, and you will have ancestors that you can reliably prove to share with your family.
Following are some blog posts and news stories that I’ve found interesting and informative. I hope you enjoy them as well.
Jim Beidler always has interesting pieces in his “Roots and Branches” column in the Lebanon Daily News. Recently he wrote about a case of double-serendipity. A dinner in memory of our late friend John Humphrey led him to a discussion with a fellow genealogist who had found a Bible from an ancestor while perusing an antique store. More serendipity occurred when Jim discovered that the owner of the Bible was also related to him. Read more in A Case of ‘Second-hand Serendipity.
Heather Wilkinson Rojo writes the Nutfield Genealogy blog about New England and other places. She recently wrote a compelling story about her husband’s family in Spain. His grandfather was one of dozens of people from the area of the village of Aranda de Duero executed by the forces of Francisco Franco during the Spanish Civil War. Recently the bodies were disinterred from their mass grave and reinterred in the local cemetery. Read more of the story in An Emotional Turn of Events.
A different, and sadder, case of serendipity occurred in the United Kingdom. A married couple had felt an “inevitable attraction” to each other from the moment they first met. Both were adopted and neither had any idea who their birth parents were. The couple married. Unfortunately, they later discovered that they were actually twins who were separated after birth when they were put up for adoption. The case has caused Parliament to start changes in adoption regulations to prevent such tragedies from occurring again. Read more in Married Couple in the UK Discover They Are Actually Twins Separated at Birth.
We are so used to hearing about horrible stories about old cemeteries being lost to the ravages of time and development or vandalized by thugs, it is nice to be able to present a story with a happy ending for a change. Two genealogists were recently looking for their Revolutionary War ancestor’s grave in Washington County, New York. They found it in a neglected family cemetery on a local farm. Fortunately, the farmer agreed to having the cemetery preserved. Read more in History Plowed Under: Descendants Discover Revolutionary War-era Graves on Farm.
Finally, we have a story that will be interesting for those who grew up in the mid-twentieth century with the words “Hi, ho, Silver!” The television show was the successor to the Lone Ranger radio series. It all started with a 1915 Zane Gray novel. But how many know the real-life man whose story inspired the legend of the Lone Ranger? Born into slavery in 1838, Bass Reeves became the first African-American Deputy U.S. Marshall in Arkansas and the Indian Territory. His story is fascinating. You can read more in The REAL Lone Ranger.
Seventy-one years ago today, on December 5, 1933, the 21st Amendment to the Constitution was ratified, officially ending Prohibition. The only attempt in our nation’s history to legislate morality, the 18th Amendment, prohibiting alcohol consumption, was a dismal failure on all fronts. No only did it not end alcohol consumption in the United States, it cost the Federal and state governments billions of dollars while it was in effect. The experiment officially ended at 5:32 p.m. EST on December 5, 1933 when the state of Utah voted for repeal. Many of our ancestors were involved in Prohibition, including those in the Temperance Movement that lead up to it, and those who made moonshine and became “rumrunners” while it was in effect. Here are some interesting facts and figures about Prohibition.
With all the excitement of Black Friday and holiday shopping, it’s easy to forget one of the most important tenets of the season — giving back to the community. Luckily, it’s easier than ever to find a way to give back this December.
In an effort to create a national day of giving to kick off the holiday season, organizations and individuals around the world are taking part in a movement known as GivingTuesday. The campaign was created last year to celebrate and encourage charitable activities that support non-profit organizations. In their words, “It’s time to ‘get out the give,’ and put ‘giving’ into the giving season.” Very similar to the way that retailers take part in Black Friday, the founders of GivingTuesday encourage the community to come together to give back during the holidays.
They have some great ideas for giving back:
1. Bring the family together to find some nonperishable foods in your cabinets. Then, bring your donation to your local food pantry.
2. Look in your closets at home and collect any extra items such as towels, blankets, etc. Donate your items to a program that sets up families in new homes.
3. At the beginning of a new season, think of one item that is needed. Then do a collection in your neighborhood for that one item and donate it to a local charity.
Check out the GivingTuesday website for more ways you can give back to the community this year.
We also can’t forget our own community! As genealogists, many of us could use some extra help breaking through our brick walls this holiday season. Inspired by the mission of GivingTuesday, we wanted to spread the word and share ideas for some of the many ways that folks can give back to the genealogy community this year.
Mocavo was founded with the belief that everyone deserves the opportunity to discover his or her family’s story. It was with this mission in mind that we created multiple free resources to empower members of the genealogy community to help one another discover his or her story.
Three Ways You Can Give Back to the Genealogy Community this Season
Modeled after Random Acts of Genealogical Kindness, we created Genealogy Karma to connect researchers all around the country. If you’re looking for information about an ancestor who lived far away, we will connect you with family history volunteers who can do this research for you in other cities. If you have some time to spare this season, try fulfilling a request for a fellow genealogist. See all requests, or become a volunteer here.
Mocavo’s Surname Groups help family history researchers tap into the collective knowledge of thousands of other genealogists. If you have information about a particular surname, share your findings by posting a message on the group’s surname page. Your information may help someone make a breakthrough in his or her own research (You can also, of course, post questions about a surname for others to respond to).
Do you have piles of research laying around? Old books gathering dust? Historical documents sitting in boxes? Now is the time to take advantage of Mocavo Free Scaninng. We scan books, documents and any standard-size paper sheets to bring them online for you and the rest of the Mocavo Community. Your dusty pile of documents could hold the clue to solve another genealogist’s riddle. Let us help you tell your story to the world.
There are many ways to give back during the holidays. Whether you give back to your local community, or the genealogy community, be sure to donate some time this December to help others in the spirit of the holiday season.
Last week I was one of millions of people participating in an event that has been officially entered into the Guinness Book of World Records: the largest simulcast of a television drama. The event, of course, was The Day of the Doctor, the 50th Anniversary special of Doctor Who. For those unfamiliar with the show, the Doctor can regenerate, at which time his appearance and personality undergo a change. This has allowed the Doctor to be played by successive actors since 1963. To me and to millions of other fans, the Doctor will always be Tom Baker, whose portrayal from 1974 to 1981 is the longest incarnation of the Doctor ever.
Doctor Who is a Time Lord, and travels in his craft, the TARDIS (Time And Relative Dimension In Space), which resembles a 1950s-era English police call box. He has been everywhere from the Big Bang to the end of the Universe and everywhere in between. And he has a particular affinity for Earth history. He accompanied on his travels by his companions (each incarnation having his own companions).
I’ve often wondered what it would be like to be able to spend awhile with the Doctor. The places I would ask him to take me. As a good genealogist, of course, I have quite the list. Starting with the village of Sorel, Quebec, in 1731. I have a bone to pick with my eighth-great grandmother, Thérèse Lavallée. I want to talk to that 27-year-old girl and ask her who the father of her illegitimate son is! Next stop would be Philadelphia in July 1766. I want to attend the funeral of Benjamin Franklin’s brother Peter and talk to his daughter. I need to find out who she married!
Unfortunately, as big a fan of Doctor Who as I am, I’m afraid that Matt Smith (the current Doctor) will not be arriving at my doorstep in a blue police call box anytime soon to give me a lift. Whilst this leaves me disappointed, there are other things I can do to answer these genealogical questions.
As to the illegitimate child born in 1731, the modern wonders of DNA testing may yet assist me. Nine generations separate me from Thérèse’s son. Eight of those generations are men. Unfortunately, my great-great-grandmother Célina Lavallée breaks that chain of y-chromosome DNA that would be helpful. Fortunately, there are other routes. Célina was one of 13 children, and five of them were sons. One of those sons, Charles, had no known children. But hopefully his brothers Pierre, Joseph, Michael, and Louis left a few male descendants who might have living male descendants. These men would carry the necessary y-chromosome DNA to identify the father of that child.
As to Peter Franklin, he is a great mystery. He was a merchant and shipmaster at Newport, Rhode Island, before being appointed postmaster at Philadelphia in 1766. We know that he had a daughter Sarah, who had two sons, but we do not know the name of Sarah’s husband. Records at Newport have many holes in them, and his occupation means that he could have easily travelled to get married, have children, etc. His daughter could have even married at quite a distance from Newport. One nephew even ended up leaving Newport for Nova Scotia. But more careful analysis of existing records for additional clues may yet reveal a solution to the mystery. And information about an adopted son of Peter may also assist in the search.
The point is that we do not always need a dashing man in a TARDIS to come by and take us back in time and space to answer our genealogical problems. Sometimes the answers may be there waiting for us. We just need to adjust our thinking, and break outside the box in our research. The answer will not come from the single push of a button on a computer, but through careful sifting of original records and analysis of the clues they leave behind. Eventually, if that doesn’t work, perhaps I shall write to David Tennant (the tenth Doctor) and Matt Smith (the eleventh Doctor) and ask them to give me a lift!
In honor of Veteran’s Day this week, have your ancestors served in the military? (click all that apply)
We asked and you answered! Last week we asked if you had any ancestors who served in the military. Over 30% of the Mocavo community poll takers have ancestors who served in the Army, and over 20% have ancestors that served in the Navy. Don’t forget to check out our bi-monthly newsletter or Facebook page to take our next poll: “Do you plan on giving any genealogy related gifts this holiday season? (click all that apply)”
As home to the first Thanksgiving in 1621, the nation’s attention focuses on Massachusetts, the Mayflower, and the Pilgrims. The perennial holiday is one of the most popular, but it is filled with misconceptions.
For example, there were no Puritans at the first Thanksgiving. Plymouth was settled by the Separatists, a different group. Today we call them the Pilgrims. The Puritans felt that the Anglican Church could be changed from within. They came directly to America from England. The Separatists felt that the Church of England could not be changed, and wanted to form their own church. They went to Leiden, Holland, before coming to America. The Puritans came later and settled the Massachusetts Bay Colony in Boston and surrounding communities. Eventually the two colonies merged. The Puritans and the Separatists are the forerunners of the Congregational Church, today the United Church of Christ.
We tend to think of Pilgrims as wearing plain clothing of black and white, with large brass buckles on their hats and shoes as well as belts. In truth, their clothing was quite bright and colorful. Their wardrobes were filled with blues, reds, browns, dark greens, and more. And buckles did not come into style until the late seventeenth century.
The Mayflower group was part of the Virginia Company, whose territory was quite vast. It was not headed to the state of Virginia as we know it today, but to the area of the Hudson River. Bad weather prevented them from going that far south, so the ship headed further north. They made first landfall at what is today Provincetown, Massachusetts, on the tip of Cape Cod. It soon moved up to what is today Plymouth, but it did not land at Plymouth Rock, nor any other rock. William Bradford’s history of the colony actually makes no special mention of their landing place in Plymouth. His wife Dorothea drowned in Provincetown Harbor when she fell overboard.
You would be surprised how much misinformation there is out there about Thanksgiving and the Pilgrims. For more information, check out Sail1620, the website of the Pennsylvania Society of Mayflower Descendants. You can also visit the website of Plimoth Plantation, a recreation of the early Pilgrim settlement in Plymouth. Visits there are almost a requirement for all Massachusetts schoolchildren. And visiting as an adult is fun as well. You can tour the village and speak to actors dressed as the Pilgrims. Don’t try to break them genealogically, though, they are used to that and very well trained! I had the pleasure of sitting down to an authentic multi-course 1627 dinner with some of the Pilgrims. It was a very interesting experience. Did you know that the fork wasn’t used in America until well into the eighteenth century?
Yesterday I saw the news break about the noted DNA testing company 23andMe. I first read about it in a Gizmodo article posted by Thomas MacEntee. 23andMe has long been in negotiations with the Food and Drug Administration about the health aspects of its testing. Yesterday, the FDA ordered 23andMe to stop selling their testing kits.
The story is picking up steam, even appearing on today’s Good Morning America. The crux of the issue is regulation of the part of the testing dealing with health issues, not the genealogical side. The concern is purported to be about the quality of the testing for medical conditions, and whether this will cause problems for people in their medical treatment.
Now, I completely understand the concern. People need to educate themselves. But, quite frankly, anyone who goes and has a double-mastectomy based on $99 take-at-home test without consulting with their physician has serious problems (not to mention the problems of a surgeon who would conduct such a procedure without doing additional testing!).
Slate had a good article about the situation yesterday, The FDA’s Battle with 23andMe Won’t Matter in the Long Run by Razib Khan. He states:
“You can frame this as an “old economy” vs. “new economy” clash. Medical testing firms are well-established sectors of the American economy, and they expect relatively tight regulatory oversight because of the nature of what they are selling. Tech companies, in contrast, are governed with a looser hand, and they sink or swim without much oversight in their first years. Based out of Silicon Valley (not to mention co-founded by Anne Wojcicki, the reportedly estranged wife of Google’s Sergey Brin), 23andMe has the blood of a tech company coursing through its veins, but it’s entering a domain which has traditionally been governed by numerous regulations.”
He goes on to comment:
“This brings us to the fact that 23andMe is just part of a broader movement toward the democratization of health information. This incident highlights the tension between the paternalistic medical establishment that arose to deal with the dangers of 19th-century quack medicine, and a ‘techno-populist’ element of American society pioneering personal health assessment and decision-making by leveraging new information technologies. Caught between them is the general public, which trusts institutions but is obviously intrigued by the offerings of consumer medicine, as judged by units sold of 23andMe’s kits.”
I agree with what Khan has to say. This is clearly a conflict of “old” vs. “new.” An additional problem is the power and influence of the established medical testing firms who resent upstarts moving past them (and cutting into their profits).
Judy G. Russell, The Legal Genealogist, weighted in on the matter today in Fooling with FDAI must say I completely agree with her conclusions. First off, the FDA will not shut down 23andMe. They are trying to force them into addressing these problems, which the company has been dragging its feet on for more than a year. And second, the FDA is not going to get involved in genetic testing for genealogy purposes. It is the other side of 23andMe’s business that is causing the problem.
In the meantime, if you are a 23andMe customer, do as Judy suggests. Download your data using all methods possible, to guard against any access issues, just in case this becomes a messier issue. Then we will all need to sit back and see what happens next.